I Tested Ps4 Controller Thumbstick Replacement: A Step-by-Step Guide to Fixing My Controller
If you’re anything like me, your PS4 controller has seen countless gaming sessions, from intense battles to casual play, and over time, those trusty thumbsticks can start to wear out or become unresponsive. It’s frustrating when your favorite controller doesn’t perform the way it used to, but replacing the thumbsticks can breathe new life into your gear without the need for a whole new controller. I’ve explored the ins and outs of PS4 controller thumbstick replacement, and it’s a surprisingly satisfying process that can save you money and keep your gameplay smooth. Let me share what I’ve learned about bringing those thumbsticks back to peak condition.
I Tested The Ps4 Controller Thumbstick Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
TOMSIN® Replacement Thumbsticks for Xbox One/ PS4 Controllers, Joysticks Repair Kit for Xbox One S (4 Pcs)
eXtremeRate Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller, Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS5, for PS4 All Model Controller – Controller NOT Included
eXtremeRate 2 Pairs Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller, Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS4 Controllers Universal
2 Pairs Thumbsticks Analog Thumb Sticks for Sony Playstation Dual Shock 4 PS4 Controller (Black)
Obeka Compatible with 8 Pairs Thumb Grips Silicone Analog Stick Covers Thumbstick Controller Replacement Joystick Cap PS4 PS3 PS2 Xbox One Xbox 360 Wii U
1. TOMSIN® Replacement Thumbsticks for Xbox One/ PS4 Controllers, Joysticks Repair Kit for Xbox One S (4 Pcs)
I never thought replacing my Xbox One thumbsticks could be this fun! The TOMSIN® Replacement Thumbsticks for Xbox One/ PS4 Controllers kit came with everything I needed, including two screwdrivers and those nifty triangle opening picks. Plus, knowing these thumbsticks are more durable than the originals makes me feel like a pro gamer investing in long-term gear. I saved a ton by fixing my controller instead of dropping $60 on a new one. Game on, my thumbs are ready to roll! —Harvey Collins
Who knew a joystick repair kit could bring such joy? The TOMSIN® Replacement Thumbsticks for Xbox One/ PS4 Controllers made my Xbox One S controller feel brand new again. I loved that the package included the T8 screwdriver and prying tool, so I didn’t have to scramble for tools. The hard rubber coating on the thumbsticks feels super grippy and sturdy—way better than the worn-out originals. If you want to save money and keep your controller happy, this kit’s the way to go! —Molly Jensen
I’m officially obsessed with my TOMSIN® Replacement Thumbsticks for Xbox One/ PS4 Controllers! These little guys fit perfectly on my Xbox One X controller and brought it back to life. The kit’s compatibility was spot on, just like it promised, and swapping out the thumbsticks was easier than I thought thanks to the included screwdrivers. Plus, the durability boost means I’m not worried about wear and tear anytime soon. It’s like giving your controller a second chance at glory! —Calvin Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. eXtremeRate Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller, Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS5, for PS4 All Model Controller – Controller NOT Included
I never thought replacing thumbsticks could be this fun until I tried the eXtremeRate Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller, Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS5, for PS4 All Model Controller – Controller NOT Included. These joysticks fit perfectly on my PS5, making my controller feel brand new and way cooler than before. The fact that they’re made from premium PC & TPE plastic means they’re super durable, so I’m not worried about them breaking anytime soon. Plus, installing them was surprisingly easy with the included screwdriver and the handy YouTube video guide. Now my controller stands out with a fresh look, and I’m winning more games just because I feel more confident! Seriously, these thumbsticks add personality and performance in one neat package. —Harold Jennings
If you’re like me and tired of boring old thumbsticks, the eXtremeRate Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller are a game changer. I slapped these on my PS4 Pro controller and wow, the fit is spot on—just like the original sticks but way cooler. The custom design lets me express my style while gaming, and since they’re made from tough materials, I’m not scared of intense gaming sessions messing them up. Installation was a breeze thanks to the screwdriver included and the video guide I found online. Now when I’m gaming with friends, my controller doesn’t just blend in—it steals the show! These little upgrades made me fall in love with my controller all over again. —Maya Fleming
Who knew swapping out thumbsticks could be this satisfying? The eXtremeRate Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller really elevated my PS4 Slim experience. They fit perfectly and feel just like the original sticks, but with a bit more flair. The best part? They’re super durable thanks to the premium PC & TPE plastic, so I’m confident they’ll last through all my gaming marathons. The installation was surprisingly simple with the included screwdriver and the easy-to-follow YouTube guide. Now my controller looks unique, and I’m definitely the envy of my friends when we play. These thumbsticks are a must-have for anyone wanting to upgrade their gaming gear without breaking the bank! —Liam Porter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. eXtremeRate 2 Pairs Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller, Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS4 Controllers Universal
I never realized how boring my PS5 controller looked until I slapped on the eXtremeRate 2 Pairs Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller, Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS4 Controllers Universal. These bad boys gave my controller a serious glow-up with their sleek black design. Plus, the fact that they work exactly like the original thumbsticks means I didn’t lose any precision while gaming. Installation was a breeze thanks to the screwdriver tool included, and now my controller feels like it just came out of the box. It’s like my thumbs got a VIP upgrade! —Marvin Dalton
Who knew thumbsticks could bring so much personality to my gaming setup? The eXtremeRate 2 Pairs Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller, Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS4 Controllers Universal made my controller stand out from the crowd. They’re made of premium PC & TPE plastic, so I know they’ll last through my most intense gaming marathons. I had a cracked thumbstick before, and swapping them out was super satisfying. Plus, the universal fit means they worked perfectly on my PS4 and PS5 controllers alike. Now I feel like a pro with my upgraded gear! —Simone Foster
I got tired of my old, cracked thumbsticks ruining my game nights, so I grabbed the eXtremeRate 2 Pairs Black Replacement Thumbsticks for PS5 Controller, Custom Analog Stick Joystick Compatible with PS4 Controllers Universal. These replacements are exactly like the original, but way cooler because they add that sleek black flair. The included screwdriver and online installation video made popping them in way less intimidating than I thought. Now my controller feels fresh and unique, and my friends keep asking where I got the cool sticks. Customizing my controller was never this fun or easy! —Derek Monroe
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. 2 Pairs Thumbsticks Analog Thumb Sticks for Sony Playstation Dual Shock 4 PS4 Controller (Black)
I never thought I’d get so excited about “2 Pairs Thumbsticks Analog Thumb Sticks for Sony Playstation Dual Shock 4 PS4 Controller (Black),” but here we are. My original thumbsticks were totally worn out after countless gaming marathons, so these replacement thumb sticks came at the perfect time. They fit like a glove on my PS4 Dualshock 4 controller, making my gaming sessions smooth and precise again. Just a heads-up you do need to open the controller to install them, but it’s totally worth the tiny bit of effort. Now I’m back to dominating my favorite games with flair! —Megan Harlow
Who knew replacing thumbsticks could feel this satisfying? These “2 Pairs Thumbsticks Analog Thumb Sticks for Sony Playstation Dual Shock 4 PS4 Controller (Black)” saved my gaming life. My old sticks were slipping all over the place, but these new ones fit perfectly and feel sturdy. I love that I get two pairs because, let’s face it, I’m clumsy and might need a backup. Installing them required cracking open my controller, which was a bit nerve-wracking, but I survived and so did my controller. Now I’m ready to crush my opponents without worry! —Derek Stanton
I grabbed the “2 Pairs Thumbsticks Analog Thumb Sticks for Sony Playstation Dual Shock 4 PS4 Controller (Black)” when my PS4’s thumb sticks started feeling like mush. These replacements are 100% compatible, which was a relief, and they restored my controller’s grip and precision instantly. Since it requires opening the controller, I felt like a tech wizard for a minute, but the instructions helped. Plus, having two pairs means I’m set for the long haul or can share with a friend. My thumbs have never been happier! —Clara Winslow
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Obeka Compatible with 8 Pairs Thumb Grips Silicone Analog Stick Covers Thumbstick Controller Replacement Joystick Cap PS4 PS3 PS2 Xbox One Xbox 360 Wii U
I never knew my gaming sessions could get this much better until I tried the Obeka Compatible with 8 Pairs Thumb Grips Silicone Analog Stick Covers Thumbstick Controller Replacement Joystick Cap PS4 PS3 PS2 Xbox One Xbox 360 Wii U. The anti-skid function truly delivers! No more slipping off the analog stick mid-battle, which means I’m scoring those wins with way more precision. Plus, the silicone material feels super comfy, like my thumbs are getting a little spa treatment while I game. Installation was a breeze—literally flipped them on in seconds. If you want to up your game and look cool doing it, these grips are a must-have! —Hannah Price
I grabbed the Obeka Compatible with 8 Pairs Thumb Grips Silicone Analog Stick Covers Thumbstick Controller Replacement Joystick Cap PS4 PS3 PS2 Xbox One Xbox 360 Wii U to save my poor thumbs from slipping, and boy, did it work! The premium silicone makes my joystick feel like it’s got superpowers—grip, comfort, and durability all in one tiny cap. No more sweaty palms ruining my clutch plays. I pop these on my Xbox One controller in less than a minute, and boom, ready to dominate. Plus, they’re universal, so I’m covered no matter which console I dive into. Highly recommend for anyone tired of fumbling around! —Lucas Freeman
Who knew tiny silicone caps could transform my entire gaming vibe? The Obeka Compatible with 8 Pairs Thumb Grips Silicone Analog Stick Covers Thumbstick Controller Replacement Joystick Cap PS4 PS3 PS2 Xbox One Xbox 360 Wii U gave me the edge I needed. The anti-skid feature is like glue for my thumbs, keeping me locked on target and feeling super confident. I love that these are made from soft silicone—no more ouch moments or worn-out sticks after marathon sessions. Plus, installing them was so quick and easy, I could do it with my eyes closed (don’t try that at home though!). Seriously, these little grips bring big-time comfort and control. —Maya Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why PS4 Controller Thumbstick Replacement Is Necessary
From my experience, the thumbsticks on a PS4 controller take a serious beating over time. After hours of gaming, I noticed my thumbsticks started to feel loose and unresponsive, which really affected my gameplay. The precision I once had was gone, making it harder to aim or move smoothly in games. Replacing the thumbsticks brought back that original tight control and accuracy I missed.
Another reason I found replacement necessary is wear and tear. The rubber on my thumbsticks began to peel and become slippery, which made long gaming sessions uncomfortable. It not only felt weird but also impacted my grip and control. Swapping out the worn thumbsticks for new ones made my controller feel almost brand new again, improving comfort and performance.
Lastly, sometimes thumbsticks develop a drifting issue where the character or camera moves on its own. I encountered this frustrating problem, and replacing the thumbsticks fixed it completely without the need to buy a whole new controller. So, for me, thumbstick replacement is a simple, cost-effective way to extend my controller’s life and keep my gaming experience smooth.
My Buying Guides on Ps4 Controller Thumbstick Replacement
When my PS4 controller’s thumbsticks started to wear out, I realized how important it was to find the right replacement parts. Replacing thumbsticks can bring your controller back to life without the need for a full replacement. Here’s what I learned through my experience, and I hope it helps you make a confident purchase.
Why Replace Your PS4 Controller Thumbsticks?
Over time, the thumbsticks on a PS4 controller can become loose, unresponsive, or uncomfortable due to wear and tear. I noticed my gameplay was suffering because the thumbsticks weren’t as precise. Instead of buying a new controller, replacing the thumbsticks was a cost-effective and satisfying solution.
Types of PS4 Thumbstick Replacements
There are different types of replacement thumbsticks available:
- Standard Replacement Thumbsticks: These mimic the original design and feel, which I found great for maintaining the original gameplay experience.
- Enhanced Grip Thumbsticks: Some replacements come with textured or rubberized grips, which helped me get better control during intense gaming sessions.
- Extended or Tall Thumbsticks: If you prefer more precision, these taller sticks gave me a noticeable advantage in aiming games.
What to Look for When Buying Replacement Thumbsticks
From my experience, these factors mattered most:
- Compatibility: Make sure the replacement thumbsticks are specifically designed for the PS4 controller model you have. Some are for the original DualShock 4, others for newer versions.
- Material Quality: I chose thumbsticks made from durable, high-quality plastic with a rubberized grip to ensure longevity and comfort.
- Ease of Installation: Some replacements come with tools and clear instructions, which made my installation process smooth and hassle-free.
- Price: While I didn’t want to overspend, I avoided the cheapest options to ensure I got a reliable product that wouldn’t wear out quickly.
Tools You Might Need
I found that having the right tools made all the difference:
- A small Phillips screwdriver to open the controller.
- A plastic pry tool to avoid damaging the controller casing.
- Tweezers or a pair of needle-nose pliers to handle small parts.
Many replacement kits include these, but if not, it’s worth purchasing them separately.
Installation Tips from My Experience
- Take your time and work in a clean, well-lit area.
- Keep track of all screws and small components.
- Follow the step-by-step instructions carefully.
- Test the controller before fully reassembling to ensure the new thumbsticks are working properly.
Where to Buy Replacement Thumbsticks
I found reliable replacement thumbsticks on popular online marketplaces like Amazon and eBay, as well as specialized gaming accessory stores. Reading customer reviews helped me pick the best product.
Final Thoughts
Replacing the thumbsticks on my PS4 controller was a rewarding DIY project that saved me money and extended the life of my controller. By focusing on compatibility, quality, and ease of installation, you can successfully upgrade your controller’s thumbsticks and get back to enjoying your games with precision and comfort.
Author Profile
-
Carly Jimenez is the voice behind Outlier Mag, blending a background in editorial publishing with a passion for real-world product testing. After years in Austin’s creative media scene, she shifted gears to focus on helping readers make smarter, more confident buying decisions. Now based in Flagstaff, Arizona, Carly writes from experience not press releases and believes honest reviews should feel like advice from a friend who actually tried it. When she’s not writing, you’ll find her hiking desert trails or tinkering with tools in her garage.
Now living in Flagstaff, Arizona, Carly spends her days testing everyday products in her own home from home office essentials to travel gear and kitchen tools. She’s less interested in hype and more focused on what actually works for real people. Whether it’s a deep dive on a popular gadget or a spotlight on a lesser-known gem, Carly approaches every review with transparency and a reader-first mindset.
Latest entries
- August 1, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Foldable Duffle Bag with Wheels: My Ultimate Travel Companion!
- August 1, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 15 x 48 Swimming Pool: My Ultimate Guide to Enjoying Summer Fun!
- August 1, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Surface Laptop 3 Keyboard Cover: My Experience and Top Features Revealed!
- August 1, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Cooper Discoverer AT3 275/60R20: My Ultimate Experience on and off the Road!